Amer Idol Redux

I didn't expect that. Congrats to him! BTW, Carrie Underwood's performance reminded me of Shania Twain. Dang those go on forever...

Amer Idol - David Archuleta...

Hands down it's David Archuleta...

Amer Idol 3

Final Round!
The World I Know - David Cook with guitar
- Definitely one record you can get by (Collective Soul) Randy
- I truly applaud you... Paula
- Nicest, sincerest contestants we have... completely wrong song choice for you... Billy Jean Simon
** Same same...

Imagine - David Archuleta
- Dude you are so good tonight you are exactly what this show is about... Randy
- ... you've left me speechless... stunning, stunning... Paula
- In my opinion you came out here to win and what we have witnessed is a knockout... Simon
** A little over the top though he could have brought this out in round one

Amer Idol 2

Round Two!
Dream Day - David Cook with guitar
- King of the duel! Sing your face off! Randy
- Great way of taking a song we don't know and loving it... Paula
- End was ok made the most of what you had, didn't feel like a winning moment for me... 6.5/10 Simon
** Rock and Roll baby!

In This Moment - David Archuleta
- You could sing the phone book and it would be good... Randy
- You are on fire tonight... Paula
- Chose the better song... round two goes to David Archuleta Simon
** Definitely much better

Amer Idol 1

Round One!
Haven't Found What I'm looking for - David Cook
- His voice was hawt! Randy
- We have found what we are looking for! Paula
- Phenomenal! Simon
** Smooothhh....

Don't Let the Sun Go Down on Me - David Archuleta
- Right time to peak! Crazy vocals! Randy
- Chills up and down my arms... so much sunshine from your singing... Paula
- Last week your were ok... tonight is the best you've done so far... round 1 to Archuleta Simon
** Voice could go higher...